2026-11-07. Stage 3, Validate. An automated cross-check against independent sources. Nobody visited the site.
The run is projects/sfb-terminal/05-checks/validation/accuracy-gates-entrances-crosswalks-2026-11-07.jsonl (74 lines, 15 confirm, 59 flag). studio.py checks folded it into the project's evidence. Nothing in the twin was moved. Each flag carries the offset, the sources and a proposed position for a person to apply.
All coordinates are the twin's frame: metres east and north of the FAA airport reference point, UTM 17N (EPSG:32617). The twin is build/latest/exploder.json (build 2026-11-06).
!Twin positions against the sources, terminal area
Summary
| Feature | In the check | Within tolerance | Off | Missing in the twin | In the twin, no independent source |
|---|
| Gates (rooms and the Gate 2 marker) | 17 | 14 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Boarding bridges | 16 | 1 | 15 | 0 | 0 |
| Terminal entrances and exits | 13 | 0 | 11 | 1 | 1 |
| Crosswalks, kerb and service roads | 28 | 0 | 0 | 28 | 0 |
- The gates are good. The twin's 16 gate rooms come from the airport's own map. 13 of 16 hold the OSM gate door inside or within 3 m of their walls. Gates 1, 15 and 16 are 3.1 to 5.8 m out.
- The boarding bridges are the weakest layer. Each sits on a "Gate N PBB Pedestal" label from a Master Plan figure. Only Gate 14's lies on its bridge. Gates 1 to 5 and 10 to 16 miss their bridge lines by 8 to 22 m. Gates 6 to 9 are 185 to 212 m off, in the car park south-east of the pier. Figure 2-18 draws the Gates 6 to 9 pier as an inset below Match Line A. The stitch placed those labels as if the inset were in true position.
- All 11 entrances are off by 34 to 91 m. The twin spreads them evenly along y = -239.6, which is across the departures road on the garage and Welcome Center side. The airport map puts the 11 doors on the terminal face at y = -197 to -206. The Master Plan's Level 1 rooms end at the same line.
- The twin has no crosswalks. OSM maps 28 crossings in the terminal and landside area. NAIP shows the paint for 16 of them within about 1 to 2 m. Five more sit under covered walkway roofs.
Sources
| Source | Date | Resolution or basis | Used for | Where |
|---|
| OpenStreetMap, one Overpass query (aeroway gate, jet_bridge, parking_position; entrance; door; highway=crossing; footway=crossing) for the SFB box 28.7635,-81.2625 to 28.788,-81.2125 | OSM base 2026-11-07T05:10:36Z | mapped by contributors; checked here against NAIP | gate doors, bridge lines, crossings | 01-intake/osm/gates-entrances-crossings.json (ODbL) |
| USGS NAIP orthoimagery, tile m_2808115_sw_17_030_20230109 (NAIP 2022 programme) | flown 2023-01-09 | 0.3 m | the bridges, the facade and kerb canopy, crosswalk paint | 01-intake/naip/terminal-0.3m.jpg, landside-0.3m.jpg (public domain; two crops, 1.3 MB) |
| flysfb.com/maps terminal map (Mappedin), one visitor page load | read 2026-11-06 | georeferenced by its maker; not refitted | gate rooms (already in the twin), 15 named door connections | 01-intake/flysfb-map/ (private, bid copy only) |
| 2021 SFB Airport Master Plan Update, Volume I, Figures 2-16, 2-18 and 2-20 | October 2021 | stitched to the twin with 1.3 to 2.8 m edge rms | the bridge labels, the Level 1 facade, the Employee Entrance label | 01-intake/master-plan/, 02-evidence/sheets/ |
| FAA NASR airport record, 29 Oct 2026 cycle | 2026-10-29 | text | gates named in remarks | 01-intake/nasr/ |
| flysfb.com maps page text, read for lockstep | 2026-10-30 | text | crosswalk count at the kerb | docs/research/flysfb-lockstep-2026-10-30.md section 2.4 |
FAA data publishes no positions for gates, entrances or crosswalks. NASR remark A110-103 names Gates 7 and 8: "PAEW ON TRML RAMP WI 75 FT OF TWY C CNTRLN WHEN ACFT USING GATES 7 OR 8". In OSM, Gate 7's stand is the nearest of all stands to the Taxiway C centre line (262 ft) and Gate 8's is 361 ft from it, which fits the remark. It does not test a position. The FAA airport diagram PDF is not in the intake.
No Google or Bing tiles were used.
Gates
Tolerance: the OSM gate door lies inside the twin's gate room or within 3 m of its wall. The 3 m is the build's own seam tolerance and sits just above the plan-stitch residual (1.3 to 2.8 m rms). NAIP at 0.3 m adds little. Each OSM gate node is the root of a jet bridge way, and each of the 16 bridge ways lies on a bridge in the NAIP image (checked by eye at full resolution). The twin's gate point is the centre of the map's gate room, so the centre-to-door distance is given as context, not as the test.
All 16 gates are on Level 2 in the twin, on the map, and at bridge height in the image. The order of gates along the piers matches OSM: 1 to 4 on the east pier, 5 to 9 on the middle pier, 10 to 16 on the west concourse. No source has a gate the twin lacks. OSM's 21 parking positions (1, 2, 3, 4, 5N, 5W and so on) are aircraft stands, not gates.
| Gate | Twin room centre (x, y), level | OSM gate door (x, y) | Door to room wall (m) | Room centre to door (m) | Result |
|---|
| 1 | -584.9, -85.8, L2 | -580.2, -108.2 | 3.1 | 22.9 | off |
| 2 | -584.0, -63.0, L2 | -579.5, -54.5 | 0.1 | 9.7 | within |
| 3 | -591.4, -63.0, L2 | -591.6, -58.6 | 0.0 | 4.4 | within |
| 4 | -592.2, -85.8, L2 | -591.0, -89.4 | 0.0 | 3.8 | within |
| 5 | -807.9, -109.7, L2 | -805.1, -114.9 | 0.2 | 6.0 | within |
| 6 | -807.5, -82.8, L2 | -805.1, -78.4 | 0.0 | 5.0 | within |
| 7 | -814.1, -48.1, L2 | -817.0, -46.3 | 0.0 | 3.4 | within |
| 8 | -816.0, -58.0, L2 | -818.8, -54.5 | 1.0 | 4.6 | within |
| 9 | -816.1, -80.8, L2 | -818.9, -88.1 | 0.9 | 7.8 | within |
| 10 | -958.4, -139.5, L2 | -963.3, -139.1 | 0.0 | 4.9 | within |
| 11 | -1016.0, -113.3, L2 | -1015.5, -114.3 | 0.0 | 1.2 | within |
| 12 | -1034.2, -94.9, L2 | -1041.3, -88.1 | 0.0 | 9.8 | within |
| 13 | -1049.9, -84.8, L2 | -1050.8, -81.8 | 0.7 | 3.0 | within |
| 14 | -1057.6, -93.8, L2 | -1067.6, -98.1 | 1.8 | 10.9 | within |
| 15 | -1056.1, -102.3, L2 | -1067.5, -104.0 | 5.8 | 11.5 | off |
| 16 | -1042.8, -115.7, L2 | -1055.7, -115.8 | 5.6 | 12.8 | off |
The Gate 2 point marker (poi-s_5b852b9cda0db060) sits inside the Gate 2 room, 9.5 m from the door. Within.
Off:
- Gate 1: the room is on the west side of the east pier at y -86. The OSM door and its bridge are at the pier's south-east corner, y -108. Door to wall 3.1 m, centre to door 22.9 m. A site look should settle which room serves Gate 1.
- Gate 15: door 5.8 m from the room. The nearest OSM door to the Gate 15 room is Gate 14's (5.7 m).
- Gate 16: door 5.6 m from the room.
Proposed: keep the rooms; add a gate door point at each OSM node on Level 2.
Boarding bridges
Tolerance: 5 m from the OSM bridge line. That allows half a bridge width, OSM tracing and the plan-stitch residual. The twin's own record gives each bridge 15 m, because the label sits off its pedestal. Against 15 m, nine bridges pass (1, 3, 4, 5, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16) and seven fail (2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 13).
| Bridge | Twin (x, y) | From figure | To its OSM bridge line (m) | Nearest bridge | Result |
|---|
| Gate 1 | -571.4, -118.1 | 2-20 | 11.8 | its own | off |
| Gate 2 | -596.0, -47.1 | 2-20 | 18.0 | Gate 3 (7.9 m) | off |
| Gate 3 | -604.4, -67.6 | 2-20 | 14.1 | its own | off |
| Gate 4 | -603.2, -100.1 | 2-20 | 8.4 | its own | off |
| Gate 5 | -795.5, -105.5 | 2-18 | 9.0 | its own | off |
| Gate 6 | -620.3, -199.7 | 2-18 | 211.8 | Gate 1 (99.9 m) | off |
| Gate 7 | -653.0, -148.3 | 2-18 | 185.4 | Gate 4 (66.9 m) | off |
| Gate 8 | -656.1, -157.7 | 2-18 | 192.7 | Gate 4 (76.3 m) | off |
| Gate 9 | -656.6, -191.5 | 2-18 | 192.5 | Gate 4 (106.1 m) | off |
| Gate 10 | -947.0, -127.8 | 2-16 | 18.1 | its own | off |
| Gate 11 | -998.3, -99.7 | 2-16 | 14.6 | its own | off |
| Gate 12 | -1029.3, -85.2 | 2-16 | 11.9 | its own | off |
| Gate 13 | -1083.3, -84.0 | 2-16 | 22.2 | Gate 14 (5.0 m) | off |
| Gate 14 | -1083.2, -90.8 | 2-16 | 1.0 | its own | within |
| Gate 15 | -1083.3, -119.8 | 2-16 | 8.7 | its own | off |
| Gate 16 | -1083.2, -131.4 | 2-16 | 10.3 | its own | off |
Two placements land nearer another gate's bridge: the Gate 2 point is 7.9 m from Gate 3's bridge, and the Gate 13 point is 5.0 m from Gate 14's. On Figure 2-16 the labels for Gates 10 to 16 stand off the building with leader lines to the pedestals, those for 13 to 16 in a column in the left margin. The build placed each label's text, so the twin's points for 13 to 16 share x = -1083. The leader ends are the better reading of the figure.
Proposed: put each bridge on its OSM line. The validation note for each gives the line's two ends. Where the pedestal sits along the bridge needs a general arrangement drawing or a site look.
Terminal entrances and exits
The twin holds 11 entrances (entrance-1 to entrance-11, Level 1). The record says the count is read from the airport map and the places are inferred, with a 40 m tolerance. The airport map names exactly 11 terminal doors: Departures Doors 1 to 5 and Arrivals Doors 1 to 6. Each is a pair of nodes, one outside and one inside, and the table uses their midpoint. The pairs are 0.6 to 12.1 m apart, the Arrivals doors widest.
Tolerance: 3 m plus half the map's node spread for that door. OSM has no entrance or door tags at SFB, so the map is the only door-level source. The facade check is independent: the Master Plan Level 1 rooms end at y -196 to -210 along these doors. In NAIP the face is under the kerb canopy near y -205. The OSM terminal outlines reach y -217 to -235 because they include the canopies.
| Twin entrance | Twin (x, y), level | Map door, same order | Map door (x, y) | Offset (m) | dx, dy (m) | Result |
|---|
| entrance-1 | -1045.1, -239.6, L1 | Departures - Door 1 | -987.5, -211.6 | 64.0 | 57.6, 28.0 | off |
| entrance-2 | -1011.1, -239.6, L1 | Departures - Door 2 | -958.8, -196.6 | 67.7 | 52.3, 43.0 | off |
| entrance-3 | -977.1, -239.6, L1 | Departures - Door 3 | -953.9, -196.8 | 48.7 | 23.2, 42.8 | off |
| entrance-4 | -943.0, -239.6, L1 | Departures - Door 4 | -911.7, -204.9 | 46.7 | 31.3, 34.7 | off |
| entrance-5 | -909.0, -239.6, L1 | Departures - Door 5 | -907.6, -204.9 | 34.7 | 1.4, 34.7 | off |
| entrance-6 | -875.0, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 1 | -843.4, -205.3 | 46.7 | 31.6, 34.3 | off |
| entrance-7 | -841.0, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 2 | -756.8, -205.7 | 90.8 | 84.2, 33.9 | off |
| entrance-8 | -807.0, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 3 | -743.7, -205.7 | 71.8 | 63.3, 33.9 | off |
| entrance-9 | -772.9, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 4 | -739.2, -205.8 | 47.8 | 33.7, 33.8 | off |
| entrance-10 | -738.9, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 5 | -714.3, -205.9 | 41.8 | 24.6, 33.7 | off |
| entrance-11 | -704.9, -239.6, L1 | Arrivals - Door 6 | -706.0, -205.9 | 33.7 | -1.1, 33.7 | off |
Each entrance is matched to the map door in the same west-to-east order. The north-south error is 28 to 43 m (median 33.9 m). Entrances 5 and 11 are right along the facade (1.4 and 1.1 m) and wrong only across it. Proposed: move each to its map door, Level 1.
Missing in the twin: Terminal to Parking Garage, Door 1, on Level 2 at (-987.6, -211.5). The map lists it as a terminal door. The map's other doors (Parking Garage Door 1, Rental Car Door, Alamo Center Door) belong to other buildings and are outside this check.
In the twin with no independent source: door-1, "Door (generic), by Employee Entrance on the plan", at (-663.3, -178.2). Its only basis is the label on Figure 2-18. The point is 6.8 m outside the OSM terminal outline, at the edge of the car park. No map door, no OSM tag, nothing visible from the air.
Crosswalks
The twin has no crosswalk items, no crosswalk layer and no ground marks for them. The 46 ground lines are taxilanes. So every crossing in the sources counts as missing.
Scope: OSM crossings inside x -1250 to -300, y -620 to -150. That covers the kerb, Red Cleveland Boulevard in front of the terminal, the landside service roads and the lots. 28 remain once each crossing node is merged with its crossing way: 22 marked and 6 unmarked. A further 34 OSM nodes carry highway=crossing and no other tag. 28 lie about 3 m apart along a lot road at y -491, five along a lot road near y -470 to -488, and one at (-738.1, -309.4). NAIP shows no crossings at them, so they are left out as a mapping artefact.
Agreement of OSM with NAIP, by eye at 0.3 m:
| Where | OSM crossings | NAIP |
|---|
| Kerb, terminal front: three ladder crossings on Red Cleveland Blvd at x -913, -839, -732, and one on Airline Avenue at x -990 | 4 | each lies under a covered walkway roof, centred on it within about 1 m; paint hidden |
| Red Cleveland Blvd to the Alamo building, x -874, y -368 | 1 | under the covered walkway; paint hidden |
| Service roads and driveways by the garage and Welcome Center (x -657, -912, -979, -881, -983) | 5 | stripes visible, within about 1 to 2 m |
| Parking aisle ladders at x -1028 (y -421 to -564) | 8 | ladders visible, within about 1 m |
| Hangar Road, x -1176, y -386 | 1 | ladder visible, within about 1 m |
| East service roads (x -433, y -485; x -404, y -507) | 2 | stripes visible, within about 1 m |
| Control Tower Lane, x -440, y -229 (tagged ladder) | 1 | no paint visible in January 2023 |
| Unmarked crossings (x -671, -578, -431, -443, -1178, -338) | 6 | no paint expected |
The flysfb.com maps page says four crosswalks cross Red Cleveland Boulevard to the terminal and one more reaches the Alamo building. OSM has the same five. OSM names the westmost kerb crossing Airline Avenue.
Proposed: add the 28 crossings at the OSM midpoints. Each validation line gives the OSM id, the ends and the marking type.
What needs a site visit
- Which rooms serve Gates 1, 15 and 16, and where each gate's door is.
- The pedestal of every boarding bridge. The figures cannot place them; OSM gives the bridge line only.
- The 11 kerb doors on Level 1 and the Level 2 garage door, with the map's door positions in hand. Its Arrivals node pairs are up to 12 m apart.
- The Employee Entrance (door-1).
- The five crosswalks under the walkway roofs, and the Control Tower Lane crossing that the 2023 imagery does not show.
- Anything built since the NAIP flight of 2023-01-09.
How it was measured
Every source was projected with the build's own UTM function (exploder/tools/build_exploder.py, utm()), so all positions share one frame. Gate test: point-in-polygon and distance to the room outline. Bridge test: distance to the OSM bridge polyline. Entrances: distance to the map door midpoint, matched by order and by nearest. The NAIP crops came from the USGS National Map image service (exportImage, EPSG:32617, 0.3 m), cropped to the terminal and the landside. The measuring scripts were run ad hoc and are not in the repository. The validation lines hold every figure in this report.